One of the first things I do when I start working with a new client is review their marketing spend. Not because I'm looking to cut things, but because where a company puts its marketing dollars tells me everything about its strategy, or more often, the absence of one.
After doing this with a lot of SMBs across a range of industries and growth stages, the same patterns show up over and over again. The same mistakes. The same budget lines that feel productive but aren't moving the needle.
Here are the three biggest culprits, and what I recommend doing instead.
Too Much Agency Spend, Not Enough Strategy
Agencies are seductive. They show up with case studies, a polished pitch, and a team of specialists. They promise to handle everything, and for a while it feels like progress: regular reports, new campaigns, a sense that something is happening.
But most SMB agency relationships suffer from the same structural problem: the agency is accountable for activity, not outcomes. They'll optimize for the metrics they control (impressions, clicks, content volume) without necessarily connecting any of that to the outcomes you care about (revenue, qualified pipeline, retention).
The other issue: agencies typically can't provide the strategic layer that determines whether you're even in the right channels, targeting the right audience, or leading with the right message. That's not what they're built for. It's what a CMO is built for.
Invest in strategic leadership first, then agency execution. With a clear positioning, channel strategy, and defined success metrics in place, agencies can execute with much greater precision. You'll spend less and get more because they're working against a real brief instead of guessing.
Paid Ads Before Organic and Owned Channels Are Working
Paid ads are one of the most common places SMBs spend first and think second. The logic makes sense: you can get traffic immediately, you can target precisely, and you can turn it on or off whenever you want. It feels controllable.
The problem is that paid ads amplify whatever you already have. If your homepage doesn't convert, paid traffic to that homepage won't convert either. If your messaging isn't clear, paid ads will spread that unclear message more widely. If your offer isn't compelling, more eyeballs won't make it compelling.
I've seen businesses spend $10,000 a month on Google Ads sending traffic to a homepage that has a 0.3% conversion rate. The math doesn't work. But it's a very easy line item to approve because it feels like growth.
Before running paid ads, make sure your landing experience converts organically. Test your messaging with owned channels like email and social first. Nail your conversion rate on existing traffic, then use paid to scale what's already working. Ads are fuel. Make sure you have an engine before you pour fuel on it.
Content Without a Distribution Strategy
Content marketing is real. It works. It's also one of the most commonly misexecuted marketing investments in the SMB world.
The typical pattern: a business decides to "do content," hires a content writer or agency, starts publishing blog posts, and after six months has a library of 25 articles that nobody is reading. Traffic hasn't moved. Leads haven't come. The business concludes that content doesn't work.
Content doesn't fail because it's content. It fails because it's written without a distribution strategy. If you don't have a plan for how each piece will reach the right audience, you're essentially publishing into a void.
Every piece of content needs a distribution plan: which keywords it targets, which audience segment it's for, which channels will carry it, and how it connects to a business outcome. Start with fewer, better pieces and put real distribution effort behind each one. One great article with a real promotion strategy beats twenty mediocre ones published and forgotten.
"The businesses that get the best marketing ROI aren't the ones with the biggest budgets. They're the ones with the clearest strategy."
The Common Thread
All three of these budget mistakes have the same root cause: spending on marketing execution before establishing the strategic foundation that makes execution effective.
Agency work is execution. Paid ads are execution. Content creation is execution. None of them work well without a strategy that defines who you're reaching, what you're saying, and what success looks like.
This is the core argument for senior marketing leadership at the SMB level. Not because you need a fancy title in your org chart, but because someone needs to be accountable for asking and answering the strategic questions before the budget gets spent. That conversation saves money, focuses effort, and connects marketing to the revenue outcomes that actually matter.
What Should You Do With Your Marketing Budget Right Now?
If you're currently spending on marketing and not seeing the results you need, here's a starting point:
- Write down every line item in your current marketing budget
- Next to each one, write the specific business outcome it's designed to achieve
- Then write how you'd know if it was working (a real metric, not "more visibility")
- If you can't answer those questions for a given line item, that's a red flag
This exercise is uncomfortable. It should be. Marketing dollars are real money, and they should be held to the same standard as any other business investment.
The good news: once you have a clear picture of what's working and what isn't, reallocation gets much simpler. And the dollars you recover from the waste column can fund the activities that actually build your business.
Want someone to review your marketing budget with you?
A marketing audit is one of the first things Ellen does with new clients. Book a discovery call and let's talk about where your budget is going and what it could be doing instead.
Book a Free 30-Min Call →